Chicago Fire – Welcome to House 51 – Part 2

In Part 2 we’re going to summarize the key story arcs from season 1. *SPOILER ALERT* This recap contains information about the entire season including the action in the finale and storylines that have been set up for season 2.

Casey and his moral compass

Casey faces several personal dramas in the first season.  At the beginning, we saw him in a relationship with Dr Hallie Thomas.  Things were rocky, mostly because Casey wanted to start a family and Hallie didn’t.  Later, Casey and Hallie break up and Hallie goes to South America to do volunteer work, only to reappear towards the end of the season.  She was killed in a fire at the clinic where she was volunteering and her death was investigated in the penultimate episode (which turned out to be caused by her discovery of the drug operation at the clinic).  Her death served the dual purpose of introducing the CPD team to viewers and it brought closure to the relationship with Casey.  Casey finished the season barely keeping it together after Hallie’s death.

Casey and Hallie

Casey also had to deal with his mother’s release from prison where she’d been serving 15 years for murdering his father.  Nancy Casey, the victim of an abusive marriage, was a thoroughly abrasive character but well played by Kathleen Quinlan.  The murder and Casey’s support of his mother caused a rift with his sister, Christie, who was less than supportive, but things seemed to improve, especially after Nancy moved out of Casey’s house to live with a former cellmate.

Casey and Nancy

Early in the season, the team was called to a car accident that was caused by Voight’s drink-driving son.  Voight attempted to cover up his son’s part in the accident but Casey submitted a report where the son wasimplicated. Voight then began a campaign of harassment against Casey and Hallie in an attempt to get Casey to change the report.  Casey was dogged in his determination to stick to his guns and this provided some really tense moments between him and Voight.  The situation was quite sad because Voight’s son clearly needed help but the teenage boy in the accident, a promising athlete, was paralysed and Voight tried to blame his father for the crash.

Casey and Voight

The tension between Casey and Voight was part of a season-long arc concerning the Voight character.  With the help of an informant, Antonio was able to put Voight away for being a dirty cop.  But by the end of the season, Voight was out of prison and had been promoted to Sergeant and head of the Intelligence Unit to which Antonio had been transferred.  This was all in aid of setting up the characters for the spin-off series.  In a nifty manoeuvre that I didn’t see coming, Voight was revealed as keeping up the pretence of being dirty so the CPD can catch some serious bad guys.  Awesome!

Voight a goodie now

There was only one story arc for Cruz in the season and it centred on his troubled brother, Leon, who was involved with some serious bad dudes.  Cruz had a solution presented to him when the head bad dude, Flacko, found himself the victim of an apartment fire.  In a bold move by the writers, Cruz let Flacko die and then had to live with the consequences of his actions which of course went against all that he had been trained to do as a firefighter.  Casey knew what had transpired and this put him in a very difficult situation. Cruz finally unloaded to Mouch who convinced him to forgive himself for what he did (for his brother) but this arc gave us an interesting insight into Casey’s leadership. The scene where Cruz finally unburdened himself to Mouch was extremely powerful but I still wonder about the resolution to this story arc.  Was it OK for Cruz to let Flacko die to save his brother from the clutches of a drug dealer?  Should there have been consequences for Cruz other than having to live with the guilt?

Cruz forgiveness

Severide (HHF) and his ambiguous moral compass

Severide had lots going on in season 1.  The main story arc of the entire season concerned a neck injury that he began the show with and which continued right through until episode 1.14.  He discovered that the injury was so serious he’d be looking at 12 months of recovery time and he just couldn’t face this.  So he covered up the injury and with the help of Shay, took painkillers to stay on the job.  This was a huge risk for both Shay and HHF, not to mention the other firefighters in the House and the people they were rescuing.  HHF reached many low points during this time including sleeping with a former girlfriend, a pharmaceutical rep, in order to obtain drugs after Shay finally gave up on supplying him.  The injury arc was resolved when HHF’s new girlfriend, Renee, found a surgeon who was experimenting with radical surgery which offered a short recovery time.  HHF’s recovery was rather miraculous, I have to say, and I felt a little bit let down by the resolution to this arc.  It covered half the season and then suddenly, HHF was back on the job.  It was just a bit too neat for me – it was set up well and it told us lots about HHF’s friendship with Shay and how HHF’s identity is tied to his job but the resolution didn’t really work for me.

But then there was this:

HHF injury

*Sighs*

The other key story arc concerned a trainee paramedic, Tara Little, who made a false sexual harassment claim against HHF. His past indiscretions –  shagging the Strumpet (Nicki, an admin officer at the House and daughter of a CFD chief) –  came back to haunt him.  He managed to get Tara to drop the charges after he discovered that she’d made a false claim before.  My view is that this story arc was designed to show us – yet again – how awesome HHF is (because you know, he’s a bit of player but still respects women) but I’m not sure that the writers thought this one through.  There was no evidence for Tara’s claim so it was her word against HHF’s. Having a woman make a false sexual harassment claim was irresponsible when we know how often women make real claims that are not taken seriously, not to mention that sexual harassment is rife in the workplace and many rape cases never get heard because of a lack of evidence.  Tsk tsk, Show.

Tara

HHF also struggled to deal with the death in the pilot episode of his long-time friend and fellow firefighter, Andy Darden.  He blamed Casey for the accident and Darden’s wife, Heather, blamed him for encouraging Andy to be a firefighter in the first place.  Later, when Heather tried to start a relationship with Casey (even though nothing happened – Casey’s moral compass at work, y’all), HHF clashed with Casey again.

Throughout all the shagging and often poor decision making, HHF remained the bad boy with a heart of gold.  He’s at his best when he’s helping people, particularly little old ladies, and the writers worked hard to show what an all round decent guy he is; this is what makes him so intriguing, the bad boy behaviour alongside the incredible kindness and emotional support he is able to give.  In episode 1.2, a man was trapped at a construction site accident and before he died from internal injuries, he recorded a message to his wife which HHF later played back to her on his phone.  I’ve watched this episode three times and it still tugs at my heart.  In another episode, HHF went into bat for an old woman who is being harassed by gang members and later, he provided brilliant support to Vargas who had to retire from the service through injury.  Sigh.

HHF with Georgie

 Relationships in the House

There were several story arcs involving personal relationships throughout the season. Casey and Dawson clearly had strong feelings for each other from the beginning and spent the season engaged in some serious UST.  This didn’t work out, mostly due to bad timing.  Casey was with Hallie then he wasn’t but it was too soon to start something with Dawson and in the meantime, she started dating Mills.  By the end of the season, the Dawson-Mills thing was off but I imagine the writers will string the Casey-Dawson UST out some more in the coming season especially since Casey is still dealing with Hallie’s death.

Dawson and Casey

The Dawson-Mills thing seemed to be fairly solid despite Dawson harbouring feelings for Casey and Mills knowing it.  (And that I spent the season wishing she was with Casey; her relationship with Mills seemed more like just a fun thing to me and he is totes punching above his weight being with her). But towards the end of the season, Mills discovered that Dawson had kept something from it that he couldn’t get past, and he called it quits on the relationship.

Mills and Dawson break up

There was a six-episode arc involving a relationship between HHF and Renee Royce, played by Sarah Shahi.  Sarah now has a recurring role on Person of Interest (as Shaw) so I imagine she won’t be around much in season 2.  Renee was rescued by Rescue Squad after she was in a car accident and her relationship with HHF developed from there (the old ‘crush on your rescuer’ chestnut).  Renee, a career woman and rather self-centred in my view, didn’t seem all that suited to HHF, and somehow didn’t ‘get him’ or the seriousness of his injury.  She ended up with a job opportunity in Madrid and despite HHF initially agreeing to go with her, he took the experimental surgery option that she had presented to him instead.  She came back in the finale – see below for more on this.

HHF and Renee

Shay wants a baby

Shay had been in a relationship with a woman name Clarice and it had ended badly some time ago.  Clarice re-entered her life after Shay and Dawson attended an incident at her baby shower.  So she’s now married to Daniel and is pregnant!  Clarice, who seems like a total manipulative b*tch, left Daniel and went back to Shay.  After the baby was born, Daniel sued for custody and even though Clarice convinced Shay that she wanted to be with her, she ended up taking a deal to move to New York with Daniel and share custody.  Poor Shay *sniff*.  After this all happened, Shay decided she wanted a baby of her own and she began searching for a sperm donor.  She decided that it was all a bit impersonal for her liking and she approached HHF to ask him to father her child (because who wouldn’t want what’s in his gene pool, right?).  Artificial insemination is really expensive so for a brief moment they considered the ‘traditional method’ but in the end, Shay’s father came up with the money for the insemination.  One attempt was made right at the end of the season which unfortunately failed.  We finished the season with a major surprise that will be interesting to see played out in season 2: HHF’s former girlfriend, Renee, who had moved to Madrid for work, returns to Chicago pregnant with what we assume is HHF’s baby.  Interesting….

fertility clinic

The whole notion of ‘Plan B’ – Shay and HHF actually having sex rather than insemination – was very irresponsible of the writers I think.  There was some humour in the way Shay presented the option to HHF but it was not well received by many fans and was made worse by an insensitive Twitter discussion about it (see link below).

Shay and the baby news

(This piece is an interesting take on the issue: http://href.li/?http://www.afterellen.com/chicago-fire-asks-twitter-fans-if-shay-should-be-de-gayed/04/2013/) There are plenty of Shayveride shippers in the fandom (please writers, do not go down that track!) and perhaps this was done to bait them, which is even worse.  Clearly Shay did not want to have sex with HHF and I’m not sure why the writers didn’t just explore the ‘turkey baster’ option.  The whole thing seemed to present the idea that lesbians are totally up for having sex with a man if the reason is good enough and it was a shame to do this to Shay when her character was doing good things for the portrayal of gay women on television.)

Molly’s bar

One of Herrmann’s key character traits is his poor financial decision making.  Around halfway through the season, the team was called to a fire in a bar and Herrmann, Dawson and Otis ended up buying the bar in a partnership.  This provided some good minor story arcs within the main arc and it gave Otis something to do.  In episode 1.17, Herrmann, Dawson and Otis tracked down the owner of a Korean War medal found in a box in a safe in the wall.  It turned out the owner of the medal had no claim on the bar but was just a friend of the eventual owner. He ‘got the girl instead’ and was married to her for 40 years.  They named the bar Molly’s after his wife and they took him to see the name unveiled *sniff*.  The bar looked like being quite successful until we found out in the finale that a swanky new sports bar will open up across the street.

MOlly

Peter Mills and the death of his father

Peter Mills, the Truck candidate, has always looked up his firefighter father.  Later in the season, HHF’s father, Benny (played really well by Treat Williams), came to visit his son and revealed that Henry Mills wasn’t such a hero after all – well in his view anyway.  It turns out that Chief Boden, who had separated from his wife, had a brief relationship with Peter’s mother while she was also separated from her husband.  Benny believes that Henry wanted to show Boden what a bad ass he was so he took his helmet off in a fire and he was killed, along with another firefighter.  Mills didn’t take this news very well at all and, along with failing to make Rescue Squad in the first round, caused him to rethink his fire fighting dreams.  We saw him at the end of the season at the Chicago police academy, contemplating a change of career.

Mills finding out

 Ernie and Chief Awesome

The Chief discovered that a teenage boy had been lighting fires and was being manipulated by his ‘uncle’ to do so.  Several episodes were dedicated to this story arc as the Chief did his best to help Ernie.  It didn’t end happily though, as Ernie was killed in a fire.  Fortunately, the uncle was apprehended even if Boden was in some strife with the CPD for doing ‘a cop’s job’. This is true Dick Wolf storytelling – not everything has a happy ending *sniff*.

Ernie and CA

Some of my favourite moments:

There are so many wonderful moments from season 1.  Some of them have already been covered but here is a selection of my other favourites:  (Apologies for the long list – and this the watered down version, too!)

1.  Anything involving rescues, particularly when HHF uses his tools *wink*. This is from episode 1.3.

HHF tools

2. Anything involving the Chief of Awesomeness.  Here he is in episode 1.3, telling Casey that “leaders lead from the front.”

ep 3

3. Shay and Dawson putting make up on a drunk guy while he was passed out in their ambulance (1.2).  Because he made a pass at Shay, you know.  This is just one of many examples of Shawson Golden Moments from season 1.

ep 2

4. HHF shagging the Strumpet in the uniform room (1.3).  She told him to keep his helmet on.  Show, you’re killing me here! (And later, HHF tells Shay that the Strumpet’s got it bad and he’s not Gandhi, by way of explanation for his actions.)

ep 3_1

5. Anything involving Shay and HHF at their apartment.  They’re usually making sandwiches and Shay’s usually in fashion disaster mode.  This one’s from episode 1.2.  Check out HHF’s shirt. And those eyes! *sigh*.

ep 3_2

6.  Casey awesomeness, in full swing throughout the entire season.  In episode 1.4, a promising young athlete is paralysed in a car accident.  At the House, their TV is on the fritz and the firefighters raise funds for a new one.  Instead of using the money for a new TV, Casey buys timber with it and he and his team build a ramp at the boy’s house *sniff*. (FYI Casey used to be in construction.)

ep 3_4

7. HHF going into bat for little old ladies.  As well as the heart string moment in episode 1.2 that I’ve already featured, in episode 1.4 he pays a visit to some serious gang dudes and tells them to lay off an old lady they have been hassling by causing small fires in her home. You go, HHF!

ep 4_4

8. Shay having a little too much to drink and lamenting her former girlfriend’s um, conversion (1.4).  “I think I overestimated her lesbianism”, she says.  Gold.

ep 4_3

9. Casey in serious mode. Here he is in episode 1.5, having a go at Voight for hassling him over his report into the drink-driving accident that implicates Voight’s son.  Check out his scary eyes.

ep 5_1

10.  But Voight is waaaaaay scarier!

ep 5_2

11. Dawson pushing a guy out of her ambulance.  “On behalf of the Paramedics’ Association of America, I offer my sincerest apologies for the forcible actions I exhibited here today”, she says.  This is in episode 1.5, after she’d been disciplined for doing something non-paramedic-ish in order to save a patient.

ep 5_3

12. “I’m coming for you, Casey”, says HHF (1.5).  Awww.

ep 5_4

13. HHF and Mills’s sister, Elise (1.7).  Adorbs.  Pity the actress who plays Elise, Alexandra Metz, now has a role in the spin-off to The Vampire Diaries #opportunitylost.

ep 7_1

14. A guy unwilling to jump onto a gantry to be rescued by HHF (1.6).  Seriously mate, what were you thinking?  I’d be there in a flash!

ep_6

15. HHF taking a bunch of flowers with him in the fire truck to give to his new girlfriend, Renee (1.10). Flowers in the fire truck!  Stopping the truck outside her house so he can deliver them!  Sigh….

ep 10_1

16, Shay’s face when Dawson backs out of asking Mills to her family gathering at the last moment and asks Casey instead (1.10).

ep 10_2

17. Shay’s face when she tells HHF she’s moving out of their apartment because he won’t seek treatment for his neck injury, as promised (1.10).  Well done, Lauren German, well done!

ep 10_3

18. Cindy being a trouper yet again and dealing with another of Herrmann’s failed business ideas (1.11).

ep 11_2

19. HHF telling Dawson that he needs help for his injured neck.  Finally (1.11).

ep 11_1

20. Shay wearing the football helmet she was given after she survived an accident where a truck collided with the ambulance (1.12).

ep 12_1

21. The friendship between Shay and HHF.  They can’t live without one another *sniff* (1.11).

ep 11_3

22. Dawson’s face when she tells the Chief a total BS story in order to help a young Mexican girl stay in the country (after her family had died in the back of a truck during the border crossing; episode 1.12).  And also the Chief, totes not believing a word of it but agreeing to the plan anyway.

ep 12_2

23. The firefighters’ WTF? faces after the attend an incident where Shay had tasered this huge guy who was obstructing the rescue (1.13).  Only she didn’t tell them about the taser, of course! (Later she asks Dawson where in the rule book it says you can’t carry a taser.  Um, I that’s on page 1, Shay!)

ep 13_1

24. Dawson and Casey, the whole season (1.13).

ep 13_2

25. Benny Severide giving his son some fatherly advice:   “Disappoint anyone, hell, disappoint everyone, but don’t ever disappoint yourself.” (Episode 1.13)

ep 13_3

26. HHF’s face looking back at Shay as he goes into surgery to fix his neck (1.13).  OMG, that faaaaace!

ep 13_4

27. Nancy, Casey’s mother, thinking Dawson is Casey’s girlfriend.  Mills looks on unamused, while eating cookies (1.14).

ep 14_1

28. Shay vacuuming away former girlfriend, Clarice, in the middle of the night.  Using a Dyson.  And then telling HHF that she wants to have a baby (1.17).

ep 17_1

29. HHF and Shay together at the CFD benefit (1.17).

ep 17_2

30. The whole House dressed in formal uniforms, forming a funeral guard of honour IN THE SNOW for a little boy whose dreams of being a firefighter were cut short due to a tragic accident (1.19).

ep 19_2

31. Dawson and Casey door shopping for an old door for the front entrance of Molly’s bar (1.20). (Anyone who follows me on Pinterest will know that I am a door geek so this has extra special meaning!)

ep 20_1

32.  HHF in uniform at the hearing into Tara’s allegations of sexual harassment.  OK, so this wasn’t actually a favourite moment plot-wise but look at his beautiful eyes!  I just had to include this. Of course.

ep 21_1

33. Dawson and Casey role playing during Sexual Harassment and Sensitivity training (1.21).

ep 21_2

34. Dawson maneuvering a snake out of harm’s way after she and Shay are called to a snake bite incident.  And for Shay for deciding to do this but then making Dawson actually do it! (1.21).

ep 21_3

35. Dawson telling Herrmann and Otis that she thinks of them as brothers (1.21).

ep 21_4

36. Anything to do with Shay and Dawson (1.22).  Did I mention that I love Shay and Dawson?

ep 22_1

37.  Officer Nicole Sermons being a total bad ass in episode 1.23 (tasers and kicking a bad due in the groin are involved here).  She’s going to be in Chicago PD, the spin-off series. Yay!

ep 23_1

38. Finding out that Voight is no longer a dirty cop; he’s just pretending to in order to clean up the mean streets of Chicago (1.23).

ep 23_2

39. More Casey awesomeness, this time in a prison fire in the season finale.

ep 24_1

40. Herrmann recording a message to his newborn son (after he took his finger off the camera, bless him). This is in the finale.

ep 24_3

41. Mouch’s online girlfriend meeting him for the first time (season finale).  When she smiled at him, I sighed.  Adorbs.

ep 24_4

42. Casey clearly not coping with Hallie’s death and Dawson being the only one to comfort him (season finale).

ep 24_5

So there you have it!  These are some of the main story arcs and my best moments from season 1.  This show has really captured my attention and I hope that S2 is going to live up to my expectations.  I have grown to love the characters on the show but can still see some issues with the storytelling which I hope are ironed out in S2.  Some of the arcs are set up well but I don’t always like the resolutions and the writers blotted their copy books with the ‘Plan B’ and Tara story lines as well as sometimes trying to cram too much in at the expense of deeper character and story development.  Not to worry, I’m on board for S2 and I’m excited to see more of the rescues and further development of the characters as well as the crossover with the spin-off series.

Bring on season 2!

season 2

Advertisements

27 comments

  1. OK–Good to go! Thanks, Briz.

  2. karin@notmcnerd · · Reply

    Great job, Andrea. I didn’t save the series on my dvr like I do all the H50 episodes, so your recap brought back some great memories!
    My dad was a firefighter who passed away many years ago. Even though his death was non-job related, his casket was carried on a fire truck. When the procession passed one of the city fire stations, the crew came out and formed an honor guard. Episode 1.19 pretty much did me in.
    I love the show and am looking forward to the new season, too. And am so excited that you are going to recap the episodes. Since I’m not on Twitter, I wasn’t able to join the discussions during Season 1. Thank you for doing this on this forum.

    1. Thanks, Karin. It will be great to have you on board, not just because we’d love to have you but also because you’ll be able to give us some insight into the firefighter stuff.

      We’re really excited about recapping the show on The Champ Box too!

      Yes, ep 1.19 did me in, too.

    2. Hi Karin! *waves* great to see you :-).

      1.19 got me as well. *hugs*

  3. Thanks!
    Now I just hope that S2 will be aired here, but you never know what will or not, but I’ll definately be reading your recaps no matter what.

    1. Glad you liked the recap, Karin. We’re getting S2 in the same week as it airs in the US but not on free-to-air television. Fortunately, I have access to it via Foxtel. I’ll probably watch the spin-off online though as there are no plans to show it here that I know of.

      So glad you’ll be reading our recaps! Yay!

      1. Lucky you!
        I’ll just have to wait and see if and when it will air here on, almost, the opposite side of the globe from you.

  4. Ugh, 42! That little shrug when he realises that his house is a tip and then remembers that he doesn’t care! That shrug really got me! 😦

    I’ll have to think of some more, there have been so many. Oh! HHF and Renee in the doctor’s office when he introduces her as his ‘giiiiirrrrrllllffffrrriiiieeennnnddd?’. *giggle*

    1. I had so many favourite moments that I had to cut down the list, otherwise I thought I’d freak everyone out. I know how much you loved the ‘shrug’ in 42. It was the shrug and then the hug that got me.

      Hehe, the way HHF hesitated and wasn’t quite sure what to call Renee. It was totes awkward *giggle*

      1. Casey really had some great moments towards the end of the season. The flying tackle in the CPD ep was a winner as well :-).

        1. I think I liked him more and more as the season progressed and once the Voight harassment thing was done with. But he really had me with the building the ramp thing for the boy who was paralysed in the car accident. Sigh. And I loved 1.23, it was one of the best episodes of the season for me. Casey was also really good in the finale even if the prison thing was a bit OTT.

          1. The prison was a bit hilarious, really. They need to seriously rethink their guard-to-prisoner ratio! I did love Casey in that ep though, I love it when he’s feisty *sigh*.

            1. When he put himself forward to save Herrmann – awesome! And coming with the idea to trick the prisoners into thinking the guard was still in the prison – awesome! But yes, the prison thing was rather amusing. McBriz snorted the whole way through. But what would he know, right? Still, not a patch on S1 of Prison Break. Now, THAT was a prison riot!

  5. Regarding the Shay/Severide “Plan B” ….at the time, the impression I was left with was Shay’s overwhelming dread and emotional distress at the idea of hetero sex… and using the show’s own dialogue, I no longer underestimated her lesbianism. Not that I had any reason to prior, but this really put a fine point on it. She was UPSET that she felt this was her only option – I didn’t think the scene was meant to show she was interested in sleeping with him AT ALL. I felt the opposite!

    Furthermore – I never assumed it would have been in Severide’s character to even consider sleeping with Shay. Yeah, he likes sex but he’s proven he’s more than that, especially where Shay is concerned. I think he was just overwhelmed by the awkwardness. He never said a word and just looked shocked (in my opinion) I didn’t get that he was intrigued at all… it was more a “what the HECK was that?” reaction… that’s what I remember anyway.

    I’m not saying people with more stake in lesbian representations on network television shouldn’t be upset — the tweets you linked to were really inappropriate — but the show itself, since the issue was resolved so quickly, I don’t think they were trying to “de-gay Shay” on the show itself.

    1. ACA! To me, Severide’s reaction was ‘I do not recall signing up for this’. And he’s never shown any sign of wanting to sleep with Shay, she wanders around their apartment with barely anything on and he doesn’t so much as look her up and down. He reminds me a lot of my beloved Riker, actually – he might take it if it’s on offer, but he’s not a sleaze.

      1. Good points, Steph and Alicia. My initial reaction was pretty much the same as yours but after reading that article and trying to see how I might react as a gay viewer, I got what the writer was saying. I don’t think Show was trying to de-gay Shay either but I still feel the storyline was a bit irresponsible. I would have been ok with the ‘turkey baster’ option and some discussion around that idea. I got that the idea of sleeping with HHF was really upsetting for Shay and I guess that’s why the writers used the dialogue that they did when Shay put the idea to him (and that was in character for her too). I think he was a little intrugued by the idea – but only a little mind you – but also quite taken aback as he doesn’t think of Shay like that. It was kind of clinical which I think is why he reacted the way he did. I am sure the writers would have expected some reaction from gay viewers and Shayveride shippers though which is why I think it was a bit irresponsible. Still, thinking about it further and reading your comments, I don’t feel so much like Plan B was a black mark. Thanks for your perspective on this 🙂 .

        1. I still think it’s a black mark because it reinforces the stereotype that lesbians will have sex with a man given the right circumstances. BBC Sherlock did it as well, with Irene Adler (who claimed to be a lesbian and then fell in love with Sherlock). If they’d played it differently it would have been OK – if Severide had said ‘Shay, you’re too fixated on the idea of having a baby, there’s no way you could actually go through with it. And I really hate the idea of having any kind of sex with someone who so obviously doesn’t want to have sex with me’ but the fact that anyone’s even debating whether either of them wanted to do it meant they made it too ambiguous, and I have a feeling they did that on purpose for the shippers, particularly when you look at the tweets and how they pushed the idea of Shay and Severide bumping uglies. I suppose you could call it straight-baiting. That’s the part of it that annoys me.

          Also if they HAD done that, Severide not wanting to have sex with someone who wasn’t into the idea would have dovetailed nicely with the Tara storyline. Which is a WHOLE other issue. Although maybe I’m doing them a disservice and they did have something like that in there, but took it out because it dovetailed too neatly.

          1. I agree! I think there are several ways they could have played it and as you say, what they did was too ambiguous. I don’t agree with all points in that article I linked to but I still stand by my view that it was irresponsible. And I agree that it seems to have been done purposely for the shippers. That whole notion of Severide being hot enough to make Shay switch teams, as was discussed in that link, is just rubbish and a huge injustice to the characters and the representation of gay characters on screen. I have read a few other things like that online so there certainly seems to be a section of the fandom who’d like to see this happen. I wouldn’t, that’s for sure.

            The one thing that is in the writers’ favour I suppose is that Shay clearly did not want to sleep with Severide but this wasn’t explored and it should have been. This is my only real beef so far with this show in terms of the writing in a general sense. Sometimes I’m not quite sure what messages the writers are trying to convey. This is how I felt with the Cruz, Severide injury and Tara Little story arcs. I think they try to do too much and mostly it’s done well but sometimes things could be explored further and then the show would be even better. Just short pieces of dialogue to try to get a better idea of what’s going on would help especially when you are dealing with such meaty topics as sexual harassment, a gay woman wishing to have a baby, and a firefighter allowing someone to die.

            Agree on the dovetail thing with Tara. Good point!

            1. They do seem to do that quite a lot, it’s the only real criticism of the show that I have – they set up these great storylines and then they don’t quite go anywhere with them. And much as I don’t need to be led by the hand, they do need to spell things out a little more than they are because at the moment we have to infer a lot and it doesn’t always come across. As you say, a little more dialogue would help a lot.

              1. ACA!! Let’s hope things are developed more in S2 and we have a clearer picture of what the writers’ intentions are – that would be nice 🙂 . As much as I love the brooding and the various other ‘actors’ faces’, a little less of it and more dialogue to explain what’s going on would be better.

              2. The show sure does put a lot of stuff out there, like the Severide injury, that seems like it’s a BIG DEAL for a few episodes and then is neatly resolved. The plus side of this is that there aren’t any long drawn out and unresolved plot lines that get so complicated that each new twist contradicts the twist that came before it — like some other shows I could mention. 😉 By which of course I mean “Heroes” and “Lost.” 😉 And in CF’s defense, they have a couple times brought back what I thought was a resolved plot line (like the transfer of Strumpet) back to impact a current one (Tara’s accusations). Which I thought was a neat trick.

                In my mind, the only real unresolved/mysterious dramatic issue is What’s Going On With The Parentals by which I mean The Chief, Momma Mills & Benny Severide… and the unraveling of all that. My thought is, if Peter broke up with Gabby over the tiny (yet critical) bit of information she kept from him, he sure as hell BETTER confront Momma Mills about it — Gabby is not the only one who kept a secret from him. But now it makes sense, if he wants out of fire fighting, because it’s “breaking up” with The Chief.

                1. I agree, the plus side is that the arcs aren’t over-egged and the pacing is good and I haven’t noticed any consistency issues. I also thought, as much as I didn’t like the false sexual harassment claim arc, that the Strumpet thing was neatly brought back into play.

                  Alicia and I have had lengthy discussions about the What’s going on with the Parentals thing and I’m still really puzzled by it. I guess Mills broke up with Gaby over the information with-holding AND a realisation that she has feelings for Casey (you think, Mills?). And yes, he needs to ask his mother about it Momma Mills said once that CA owes her one and I’m still not quite sure why. I mean, both couples were separated when CA became involved with her and the whole ‘Henry was trying to impress Boden by taking off his helmet and that’s why he died in the fire’ is a bit lost on me. I’m not sure Mills knows what he wants really.

  6. Awesome recap!!! I have been on board with the team from Firehouse 51 since the premier. Love the show, love the writing, absolutely love the friendships. Thanks for adding this to your repitoire! Can’t wait for Tuesday

    1. Hi Nance, glad you liked the recap and so happy to have found someone else who loves the show as much as we do. I’m looking forward to your comments once we start recapping S2. Bring it on!

  7. Julia (Major CF Fangirl!) · · Reply

    OMG, this is my new favorite site, and the S1 favorite moment pictures were amazing! You did an amazing job- and now I have to go follow you on twitter and pinterest! 🙂 I can’t wait for more, and will be checking this site often! 🙂
    AMAZING JOB!
    -julia

    1. Thank you so much *hugs*. Really glad you like our blog; we’d love you to comment on the episodes on our weekly recaps. I followed you back on Pinterest and will check out your boards later (it’s early here in Oz). Welcome!

  8. duckygua · · Reply

    hey andrea. i found this site as i was trying to figure out if Christie is Casey’s older sister or younger. the reason is that i’m a subtitler in Japan and now working on this show, and in Japanese, we always have to clarify older/younger when it comes to siblings– we say like, “hey it’s my older sister so and so” or “how’s your younger brother?” and so on. since Christie is one of the key characters in this show, i definitely have to say she’s older or younger… do you know or have you figured out? on the earlier episode in season 1, casey mentions to her that she was away in college dorm while he was at home looking at their mother beaten by their dad, so i figured casey was still in high school or something– so he’s her younger brother??? also, the actress who plays Christie (Nicole Forester) is like 7 years older than Jesse Spencer, so naturally, she’d play an older sister to him, i’d say? but i’m not sure. it’d be wonderful if you can give me your thoughts on this! thanks in advance 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: